Posted on March 2, 2023
Historical dredging and wetland loss in New York City’s Jamaica Bay have increased high-tide flooding in the area, according to a new study.
Jamaica Bay is an estuary that lies between Long Island and New York City’s Brooklyn and Queens boroughs. Over the past 150 years, landscape changes and sea level rise have increased high-tide levels in the bay by 55 centimeters (1.8 feet). As a result, hundreds of thousands of residents experience chronic, damaging floods.
“Some neighborhoods around Jamaica Bay flood about 60 times per year,” said Philip Orton, a physical oceanographer at the Stevens Institute of Technology and corresponding author of the study. “This forces the community to make infrastructure changes, like putting backflow valves in sewers to prevent water from coming up during flooding events.”
The study was published in AGU’s Journal of Geophysical Research: Oceans, which features science that advances our understanding of the ocean and its processes.
Researchers used water level observations and digitized landscape maps that extend back to the 1870s to model the effects of sea level rise and land-use changes, including the extension of Rockaway Peninsula and the dredging and widening of the inlet, on high-tide flooding in the bay. They then compared modern flood risks to hypothetical scenarios in which humans did not alter the landscape.
In 2020, 15 of the 62 high-tide events that impacted Jamaica Bay were classified by NOAA as “minor” floods, resulting in flood advisories throughout the bay. According to the study, only two of the 15 minor flooding events that impacted Jamaica Bay in 2020 would have occurred if there hadn’t been historical landscape changes in the bay, and only one of the 15 would have occurred without sea level rise.
“We know that flooding is going to get worse, and institutions will have to plan to provide aid to people living in the area,” said Alfredo Aretxabaleta, an oceanographer at the United States Geological Survey with no affiliation to the study. “This research provides the framework to identify the most beneficial ways in which to lessen the impact of minor flooding in shallow, urbanized coastal lagoons.”
‘Minor’ flooding, major problems
Minor flooding events, often called nuisance flooding, are floods that result in minimal property damage but may pose a public threat or inconvenience. “Basically, when there is street flooding, it is considered a minor flooding event,” Orton said.
High-tide floods often fall under the category of “minor” floods, but chronic minor floods—such as the those that residents face monthly around Jamaica Bay—can disrupt the livelihoods of the bay’s residents and cause infrastructure damage over the years.
“We thought that the main [flooding] problem was going to be that the inlet was deepened dramatically in the 1870s,” Orton said. “But it turns out that the destruction of the surrounding wetlands was also an important factor in the flooding dynamics of the estuary.”
The wetlands surrounding the bay had absorbed the tidewaters, reducing flooding by allowing the water to spread over a wider area. In the late 1800s, 46.5 square kilometers (18 square miles), or 76%, of the total wetland area was lost due to erosion, inlet deepening and the creation of new urban spaces. Today, neighborhoods are built on top of the remaining wetlands.
“When people think of flooding, they tend to consider it as a result of extreme events, like hurricanes,” said Aretxabaleta. “Minor floods may not be as detrimental as hurricanes, but they can flood your basement and damage the foundation of your house, and people are getting tired of dealing with them.”
It doesn’t help that many communities vulnerable to chronic high-tide flooding in the United States are located where tropical storms and hurricanes tend to hit, Aretxabaleta added.
“At many locations across the nation, high tides are getting higher thanks to sea level rise,” Orton said. “Many of the developed coastal lagoons throughout the country, and even throughout the world, are being hit with a growing number of high-tide flooding events.”
Restoring wetlands and marshes around the edges of Jamaica Bay could help reduce high-tide flooding, Orton said.