Posted on November 16, 2026
Lucy Reuben wants to build a house on the lot where her grandfather once had a three-bedroom cabin. It’s a way to continue her family’s legacy at McKenzie Beach, which was a thriving Black resort during the segregation era.
“We are looking for opportunities for generations-long family fellowship while continuing to preserve the historical and cultural treasure represented by McKenzie Beach,” she said.
But the property that her family has owned for over 80 years is less than 5,000 square feet, just under 50 feet wide and 100 feet long. It’s now in a “general commercial” zoning district off Highway 17 where the minimum lot size is 10,000 square feet and the building setbacks would eat up all the usable space.
So Reuben asked the Georgetown County Board of Zoning Appeals to grant a variance to the setbacks and allow construction on a substandard lot that was created about 75 years before the county adopted zoning regulations.
“We look forward to helping revitalize the family-oriented culture, legacy of McKenzie Beach,” she told the board at a hearing last week.
The request drew opposition from other owners at McKenzie Beach, which extends from the highway to the oceanfront. A bridge that spanned Clubhouse Creek washed away in Hurricane Hazel in 1954.
Gladys Watkins and her son, Evan, told the appeals board that while they respect Reuben’s property rights, they questioned the extent of the variance, which would reduce the front setback from 50 feet to 10 feet.
“Our family is not opposed to reasonable development. We are committed to preserving McKenzie Beach and ensuring that decisions affecting this historic property are made carefully, fairly and in accordance with the law,” Gladys Watkins said.
She and Toddy Smith, a partner in McKenzie Beach LLC which owns most of the surrounding property, also raised concerns about the private road that provides access to the Reuben lot.
“It’s a private road owned by the people who own the rest of McKenzie Beach,” Smith said.
Dan Stacy, the attorney who represents the LLC, told the board that even though Old Beach Road may provide access to the lot “that does not automatically include a development easement where you have the right to run water and sewer, and utilities, and electric and communication.”
“Those documents are not in place, and there is no recorded right to do that,” Stacy said.
Granting the variance request as well as approval to build on a substandard lot would amount to an “advisory opinion” from the appeals board, he said.
“I don’t want this board to be in a position where it grants variances for a home that can possibly never be constructed without the access or all the other utilities necessary,” Stacy said.
Granting the variance request would set a precedent for seven other substandard lots along Old Beach Road, Smith said.
“They could come in and ask you the same thing,” he told the board.
Smith also pointed out that there are four conditions that must all be met under state law to grant a variance. One is that the conditions on the lot for which the variance is sought don’t apply to other property in the vicinity.
“You have seven other ones with essentially the same conditions,” he said.
Since buying an interest in the property 22 years ago, Smith said he has heard from many people who want to develop McKenzie Beach.
“What we want to protect is the beauty and history of that, and we do not think that having substandard lots in there, a whole subdivision, is consistent with that,” Smith said.
Reuben told the board that all the objections came from a single entity, McKenzie Beach LLC. She pointed to a 2013 appraisal that set the value at $9.5 million for the tract.
The appraisal “suggests that the LCC business entities have been considering significant commercialization and subdivision, which would drastically alter the character and culture of McKenzie Beach,” she said.
Reuben also told the board it would have been easier to rebuild in the footprint of her grandfather’s cabin, but the remnants were removed under circumstances that are not entirely clear.
Staff recommended approval of the variance request. Board members said the setbacks would be reduced if the property were rezoned from commercial to residential use, and that without a variance the lot would be unbuildable.
Board member Kenneth Reed said under the current zoning Reuben could use her property as a storage facility. “Be careful what you wish for,” he told the opponents.
Whether Reuben’s proposed house can be built is not an issue, board member Adam Hall said. “We’re not approving a building permit.”
But board member Jason Goude said the road was an issue they should address. He moved to defer a decision until they could get more information about its ownership.
“I don’t deny any of the claims made this evening from both parties,” he said, but if the ownership isn’t resolved “it’s going to be an ongoing issue.”
The board agreed.
Smith said he had title work done before buying into McKenzie Beach.
Reuben said she hasn’t seen where anybody’s paying taxes on the road, which appears on county property records.
“But I’ve been walking that road for more than 70 years, and I walked it today,” she said.